So I decided to repaint it. I started by cleaning the pieces off really good, letting them dry and sanding down the rough spots where the previous paint was peeling. I found a bright red spray paint at Home Depot for about $3 per can. Here is the paint I used:
Once the pieces were dry from their hose down and wipe off, I set to work.
After two-ish coats of paint, I let the pieces sit until the following afternoon before stacking them together. Et voila!
What do you think? Have you re-purposed items from your home in your garden?